The Criticism of Tafsīr Narrations
No Cover

The Criticism of Tafsīr Narrations

Transmission, Meaning, and Authorial Intent

Dr. Sheikh Saad Slaoui Andaloussi

The Criticism of Tafsīr Narrations

Transmission, Meaning, and Authorial Intent

By Dr. Sheikh Saad Slaoui Andaloussi

How should the narrations preserved in the classical books of Tafsīr be evaluated? Does a weak chain of transmission necessarily invalidate a report's meaning? Does the inclusion of a narration in a major Tafsīr work indicate its authenticity? And did the scholars of Hadith and Tafsīr truly follow different methods of criticism?

In The Criticism of Tafsīr Narrations, Dr. Sheikh Saad Slaoui Andaloussi offers a comprehensive scholarly examination of these questions, challenging oversimplified approaches to Qur’anic interpretation and recovering the depth and sophistication of classical Islamic methodology.

The book presents an integrated framework built upon three essential dimensions:

Transmission: Examining the authenticity of reports, the reliability of narrators, and the principles governing attribution.

Meaning: Distinguishing between the authenticity of a narration and the validity of its interpretation through language, Qur’anic context, and corroborating evidence.

Authorial Intent: Understanding why classical exegetes preserved particular reports and why citation does not necessarily imply authentication.

Across 23 chapters organized into seven major parts, the author explores the relationship between the Muḥaddithūn and Mufassirūn, the limitations of relying exclusively on isnād analysis, the principle of predominant probability (ghalabat al-ẓann), and the distinctive characteristics of transmitted Tafsīr.

Special attention is given to the methodologies of Imam al-Ṭabarī and Ibn Abī Ḥātim, alongside practical case studies examining classical exegetical reports and common errors in modern scholarship.

The book also includes technical terminology, references to major classical sources, a practical analytical framework for researchers, a bibliography, and indexes.

Written for students of Islamic knowledge, researchers, imams, educators, and serious readers of the Qur’an, this work demonstrates that authentic scholarship requires more than mechanically accepting or rejecting narrations. It demands a disciplined understanding of transmission, meaning, context, and scholarly purpose.

A valuable resource for understanding the methods through which generations of Muslim scholars preserved, examined, and interpreted the Qur’anic tradition.

Sheikh Saad Publications

Book Info

Publisher Sheikh Saad Publications
Release Date 2026-10-25
Page Count 335 Pages
File Size 2 MB
Language en-US

No download link available yet. You can .

Related Books

Similar recommendations you might enjoy

Join Telegram